The Lawsuit That Could Change Major League Baseball Forever

Major League Baseball filed a seemingly innocuous lawsuit Friday that could actually have an enormous impact on several teams’ lineups do to civil discovery rules. On March 22, MLB sued the now-shuttered clinic Biogenesis and its operators, including embattled “Dr.” Anthony Bosch, in Miami Dade County Circuit Court accusing them of scheming to provide banned performance-enhancing drugs to players in violation of their contracts. (the complete lawsuit is after the jump).

At first this lawsuit appears laughable. MLB actually has the nerve to sue someone else because its players use performance enhancing substances. The Complaint alleges that “soliciting Major League Players to purchase or obtain PES, and/or by selling, supplying and/or otherwise making available PES to Major League Players” caused MLB to suffer unspecific economic damages including, “the costs of investigation, loss of goodwill, loss of revenue and profits and injury to its reputation, image, strategic advantage and fan relationships.”

I’m pretty sure have Bud Selig turn a blind eye to steroid and PES use for decades is what ruined MLB’s image. Or the four hours games, lack of instant replay, and the creation of winning monarchies by blowing up the notion of a salary cap. But I digress.

What makes this lawsuit so huge is that MLB filed it solely in hopes of obtaining the documents Bosch reportedly turned over to various news outlets. Specifically, MLB wants to use civil discovery avenues to access the following:

In January and February of 2013, the Miami New Times, a free Miami-area newspaper, published what it claimed were excerpts from handwritten records maintained by Defendant Bosch while he was affiliated with Biokem and/or BioGenesis, which the Miami New Times stated it had received from a confidential source. Other media outlets, including Yahoo! Sports and, have published additional records purportedly maintained by Bosch. Upon information and belief, the excerpts published by the Miami New Times and others—which reflect Defendants’ sales of PES to Major League Players—are authentic business records, and come from personal notebooks and records maintained by Bosch while he was affiliated with Biokem and/or BioGenesis.

By filing this lawsuit, if Bosch has not already destroyed the documents then he is now on notice to preserve his business records for discovery or face an adverse inference jury instruction and/or sanctions.

These documents could potentially implode many MLB rosters. Among those implicated by these missing documents are New York Yankees third baseman Alex Rodriguez, outfielder Melky Cabrera of the Toronto Blue Jays, Washington pitcher Gio Gonzalez, Oakland pitcher Bartolo Colon, Texas outfielder Nelson Cruz and San Diego catcher Yasmani Grandal. Most have denied the Biogenesis link, although Rodriguez has admitted using performance-enhancing drugs earlier in his career and Colon, Cabrera and Grandal were each suspended for 50 games last year for testing positive for elevated testosterone levels.

The lawsuit also contends that former star Manny Ramirez, who is now signed to play for a team in Taiwan, obtained a prohibited substance from Bosch in 2009 that ultimately resulted in Ramirez’s 50-game suspension by MLB when he was with the Los Angeles Dodgers. The suit marks the first time MLB has gone on the record saying Ramirez tested positive for the female fertility drug HCG, or human chorionic gonadotropin.

It is hard to imagine that MLB really cares about whatever dollars it can recover from this now defunct clinic. The documents linking MLB players to Bosch are vital to MLB’s continued investigations into the PES rumors. Most likely they are gone, but this is a very creative strategy by MLB’s lawyers to use subpoenas, depositions, and discovery rules to their advantage.

This entry was posted in Articles. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Lawsuit That Could Change Major League Baseball Forever

  1. Carter says:

    Very interesting; I have been curious how “handwritten records” would hold up in court? For instance, if he wrote “Sold 500 mg of (drug) to (MLB Player)” in a notebook, but had no corroborating signatures, how would this be handled as “evidence”?

  2. Administrator says:

    Good question Carter. If it can be authenticated as to who wrote the record and when it was done then it is circumstantial evidence that a jury would have to consider. Obviously the credibility of the source and the amount of verifiable detail in the records would have a huge impact if they would matter at all.

  3. Michael Doelfs says:

    What about damages? ‘Unspecified economic damages,’ are, at some point, going to have to be quantified. Wouldn’t that mean that MLB, and all it’s clubs, would have to open their books? If they are claiming loss of revenue and profits, at some point they would have to show it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>